Closed-loop card vs open-loop card: where you can actually use it
-
Key takeaways
A closed-loop card can only be used at a specific merchant or group of affiliated merchants.
An open-loop card carries a payment network logo and can be used almost anywhere that network is accepted.
Most gift cards are closed-loop; most prepaid, payroll, and government benefit cards are open-loop.
Closed-loop cards generally have fewer consumer protections than open-loop cards if lost or stolen.
Understanding the difference matters when choosing a delivery method for money being sent internationally.
A closed-loop card looks like a payment card, but it can only be used in specific places. Here’s how it differs from an open-loop card and why it matters when receiving money.
What is a closed-loop card?
A closed-loop card is a card that can only be used at a specific merchant, or a specific group of affiliated merchants, rather than being accepted broadly. According to the CFPB’s definitions for prepaid cards(opens in new window), a closed-loop card might be good only at a particular store, group of stores, or a public transportation system, and most closed-loop cards don’t carry a payment network logo.
Closed-loop card vs open-loop card: key differences
Closed-loop card | Open-loop card | |
|---|---|---|
Where accepted | Limited to a specific merchant or affiliated group | Broadly accepted wherever the payment network is honored |
Typical use case | Store or brand-specific gift cards | Prepaid, payroll, and general-purpose reloadable cards |
Recipient access | Cannot be used for cash withdrawal in most cases | Can often be used at ATMs and for a wide range of purchases |
International usability | Generally not usable outside the issuing merchant’s network | Usable internationally wherever the network is accepted |
Why the difference matters for receiving money
Most closed-loop card content is written in a retail gift-card context, but the distinction has real consequences for anyone receiving money on a card:
A closed-loop card can’t be used to receive an international transfer. Since it only works at a specific merchant, it isn’t a viable receive option for money sent from abroad.
Consumer protections differ. Open-loop cards issued by a financial institution are generally covered by federal electronic transfer protections, while closed-loop cards typically have fewer formal protections if lost or stolen.
Most cards relevant to money transfers are open-loop. Prepaid cards, payroll cards, and government benefit cards used to receive funds are almost always open-loop.
Closed-loop and open-loop cards and international money transfers
Understanding this distinction helps senders choose the right delivery method, since a money transfer needs to land on an open-loop card, a bank account, or another compatible delivery method, never a closed-loop card tied to a single retailer.
Considering returning or reusing a gift card(opens in new window) that’s been received is worth knowing about, since most closed-loop gift cards can’t be converted into cash or used for anything beyond the issuing merchant, which limits their flexibility compared to an open-loop option.
Common examples of closed-loop cards
Closed-loop cards are more common than the term itself might suggest, since many everyday gift cards and store credit cards operate on exactly this model. A specific retailer’s gift card, a coffee shop’s reloadable card, or a mall gift card that only works at participating stores within that mall are all closed-loop by design. These cards serve their intended purpose well within a specific, narrow context, encouraging repeat business at a specific retailer, but they’re fundamentally unsuited as a general-purpose way to receive or hold money, since their usability outside that specific context is either extremely limited or nonexistent.
Why closed-loop cards occasionally show up in scam schemes
Because closed-loop gift cards are widely available, easy to purchase anonymously with cash, and difficult to trace or reverse once the funds are spent, they’re unfortunately a common tool used in scams, where a fraudster asks a victim to purchase gift cards and provide the card numbers as a form of payment. Legitimate businesses, government agencies, and family members in a genuine emergency essentially never request payment specifically in the form of gift card numbers. Being asked to pay a bill, a fine, or help a relative in an emergency using a specific retailer’s gift card is worth treating as a serious warning sign of fraud, rather than an unusual but legitimate payment method.
Common questions about closed-loop and open-loop cards
-
Can I send an international transfer to a closed-loop card?
No. A closed-loop card only works within a specific merchant’s system and cannot receive funds from an international money transfer. Recipients need an open-loop card, a bank account, or another compatible delivery method instead.
-
How do I know if a card is closed-loop or open-loop?
An open-loop card typically displays a payment network logo, such as Visa or Mastercard, indicating it’s accepted broadly. A closed-loop card usually lacks this logo and instead displays only the specific retailer or service it’s tied to.
-
Are closed-loop cards as safe as open-loop cards if lost or stolen?
Generally, no. Open-loop cards issued by a financial institution typically carry stronger federal consumer protections against unauthorized use. Closed-loop cards often have more limited protections, and recovering a lost or stolen closed-loop card’s balance depends heavily on the specific issuer’s own policy.
In Summary
A closed-loop card works only within one merchant’s system, while an open-loop card functions broadly, and this distinction matters directly for anyone choosing how to receive money from abroad. Understanding which type of card is involved helps in avoiding an option that simply won’t work for an international transfer.
This publication is provided for general information purposes only and is not intended to cover all aspects of the topics discussed herein. This publication is not a substitute for seeking advice from an applicable specialist or professional. The content in this publication does not constitute legal, tax, or other professional advice from Remitly or any of its affiliates and should not be relied upon as such. While we strive to keep our posts up to date and accurate, we cannot represent, warrant, or otherwise guarantee that the content is accurate, complete, or up to date.